Skip to content

Monday, October 19, 2026

Discover. Cook. Enjoy.

Soft Key Lime Pie

Soft Key Lime Pie

By Jordan Lee ·

Prep
20 min
Cook
12 min
Servings
8 servings
Cuisine
American

Skip to recipe

Soft key lime pie is the cold dessert I make when citrus feels right and I do not want a complicated pastry. Graham crust gets a short bake so it holds. Filling is condensed milk, lime juice, zest, and egg yolks, and the condensed milk sets it without gelatin. I give the filled pie a brief bake so the eggs are safe, then chill hard. Whipped cream goes on right before serving. Real key limes if you find them; regular limes work fine most weeks.

Servings
8
servings

Ingredients

Steps

Equipment

23 cm pie dish Mixing bowls Whisk or mixer Measuring jug Spatula

Reviews

No published reviews yet. Be the first after you cook it.

Leave a review

Reviews are moderated before they appear. Ratings never publish automatically.

Explore

More to cook next — up to eight, never including this recipe.